Showing posts with label Bates Method. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bates Method. Show all posts

Friday, January 29, 2010

29. Contradictions

This is the heftiest entry in here, both lengthwise and in its subject matter. If you're just tuning in, I recommend looking at this other post as a launching point for doing some eye exercises.

In all of my research that has led me to writing this blog, I've read writings by and visited people who all claimed to be "experts" in the field of something related to the eyes and their health. Some of these people have the clout of the Western Optometrical Complex to back them up, many others ousted themselves from that institution because they felt that prescribing stronger and stronger leses for people was hurting, not helping their eyesight. Others still were never professional optometrists, but people who entered into this work through a route of holistic and natural healing. With so many "experts" coming from so many philosophies, traditions and experiences, it is inevitable that their statements contradict one another.

Below are some of the contradictions that I've come across in my own experience with natural vision therapy, as well as how it relates to the Western Optometrical Complex. Nothing here is conclusive because I can only put myself out there as an expert regarding my own experiences with vision—not yours or the billions of others who live and have lived on this planet. Also, healing practices must be in constant dialogue, never set in stone, for there were many certainties that doctors had for centuries that we now know to be false. Who's to say that certainties of today's doctors, pharmacists, scientists, and drug company executives are any more true than those who believed that the common cold was caused by evil spirits? Read on, try things out, question everything and let me know what you come up with:
  1. "Corrective" Lenses vs. "Opposite" Lenses: Mainstream western optometry works like this: you go to the eye doctor and get a prescription for lenses. Over the course of the year, your eyes adjust to the lenses and then you need a stronger prescription. In functional optometry (though it's difficult to find documentation of this in any book) doctors will have patients wear "opposite glasses"—lenses that actually make the vision "worse." This means that a farsighted person would be given a negative or nearsighted pair of glasses, and a near sighted person would be given a pair of positive or farsighted glasses. The glasses are only worn for about 20 minutes at a time, maybe once or twice a day, the vision is only worsened for this short time. But when the glasses are removed, the vision might actually be better. The theory is that if a pair of "corrective" lenses pull a nearsighted person deeper into nearsightedness and a farsighted person deeper into farsightedness, than "opposite" glasses can do the opposite.
  2. Staring vs. Shifting: In Ayurvedic, yogic, and many martial arts practices, there is this idea of gazing at a fixed point or a flickering flame to relax the mind and improve the vision. Dr. William H. Bates and his protégés protest against this, saying that the eyes should be in constant movement. this is one of Bates' key principles, just as finding one's drishti is a key principle in many schools of yoga.
  3. Centralization vs. Peripheralization: With the tradition of Batas and post-Bates natural vision therapy, I've come across a couple of different recommendation regarding the role of peripheral vision. According to Thomas R. Quackenbush, much of our culture's eyestrain comes from trying to see everything at once—the "Big Picture" with everything in equal focus.
    Quackenbush posits that only the central vision—where the cone cells are concentrated in the fovea—should be clear, and that the peripheral vision—where there only a smattering of rods to indicate base might, shadow and movement—should be blurry. He goes on to state that it is this trying to get the rods to pull in a sharper image that puts strain on the eyes and makes the whole vision go blurry. Meir Schneider, on the other hand, promotes exercises that strengthen the peripheral vision. Both men are followers of the Bates Method and both have succeeded in improving their vision through its practice, though their individual experiences are different and perhaps this is why they differ on this particular aspect of Bates' teaching.
  4. Lutein vs. Beta Carotene: The irony of this one is that both of these nutrients have been shown to support the vision, yet each blocks the other's absorption! Dr. Marc Grossman, with his experience both in functional optometry and Chinese Medicine, says that beta carotene is best absorbed in the middle of the day (11 AM to 3 PM) and lutein in the middle of the night (11 PM to 3 AM). IT's a pretty weird regimen to follow, but really not any weirder than any of the exercises I've posted on this blog, right?
I am very interested in healthy debate in the interest of actually making people healthier rather than the "I'm right, they're wrong, and I've got all these books and fancy degrees to back me up" sort of thinking that gets thrown at me by almost anyone wearing a lab coat. I've have several conversations with doctors about eye exercises like Sunning, and practices such as wearing pinhole glasses, that went absolutely nowhere. If you've had any experience with this stuff, or have questions about anything here, leave your comments here.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

17. Breathing

The Idea: All the systems of the body need oxygen to function properly. This is especially true for the eyes. By focusing on the breath we set an intention to bring oxygen to the eyes and brain. Conscious breathing also helps the body and the mind to relax. This is essential for developing greater vision.

How To:
Step 1: Sit, stand, or lie down in a comfortable and relaxed position. It can be helpful if you can look off into the distance.
Step 2: Notice the shoulders—are they relaxed? Relax them. How about the neck? The jaw? The face? Relax these too.
Step 3: Notice the breath. Inhale fully, expanding the ribs outward and upward. Exhale completely, drawing the navel toward the spine. Keep Keep relaxing shoulders, neck, jaw and face as you inhale and exhale.
Step 4: Deepen the breath. Make each inhale and each exhale a little bit longer than the one before it.
Step 5: Pause at the top of your inhales, holding the breath in and filling the full the expansion of the lungs. Pause at the bottom of you exhales, feeling the effects of tucking the navel in toward the spine.
Step 6: While you do this, look off into the distance, allowing the eyes to relax as they breathe.

When to Practice Deep Breathing: Do this breathing exercise every day. Practice deep breathing while practicing any other eye exercises. Also remeber to breathe deeply while doing other things that work the eyes, such as reading and writing. Are you breathing right now?

More Info:
• All forms of yoga and meditation highlight breathing as a core principle of their practices. Some of the cues given above come from Ana Forrest, founder of Forrest Yoga.
• All natural vision teachers also highlight breathing as a key to greater vision. Marc Grossman, Meir Scfneider and Tom Quackenbush all put breathing first in their instructions for working toward better eyesight. Even skeptics of natural vision therapy attribute improvements in people's sight via these methods to the practives of breathing and relaxation.

Saturday, January 16, 2010

16. Your 5-Minute Regimen

Last night I was onstage and I asked the crowd if they had any questions. Someone said, "What are you doing for Fun-A-Day?" and I told them that I was doing eye exercises every day and sharing how others could do this via this blog. Someone straight-up laughed at me, which I found refreshing—laughter is good for the vision.

For those of you just tuning in, every day I post something here that you can do to benefit your eyes. Some of these things are "eye exercises" that you can do for a little time each day, others are "vision habits" that help the eyes relax through taking better care of them in general. Having a new thing every day might be a little overwhelming, so midway through this project let's pause to compile some of these exercises and habits into 5 minute routines that you can do morning noon and night. Try it out, then leave me comments (and laughter) about your experiences:

5 Minutes in the Morning
Do these exercises in a sunny spot:
If you feel like going a little longer, repeat the exercises in the same order.

5 Minutes in the Middle of the Day
You can do these exercises sitting in a chair:
Note that Directions and Neck Stretches can also be done simultaneously by combining Diagonal Directionals with Side Neck Stretches, or doing Rotational Directionals with Diagonal Neck Stretches, etc.

5 Minutes in the Evening
These exercises can be done right before going to sleep:
For a longer practice, continue Palming for as long as you like. Palming can also be combined with Buzzing.

Vision Habits to Remember:

Friday, January 15, 2010

15. Sketching

The Idea: Part of seeing clearly is the ability to discern edges. When vision is blurred, one might not be able to tell the definite shape of something, or exactly where one object begins and another ends. By paying attention to edges, we can teach ourselves to better define what we see.

How To:
Step 1: Use the tip of your nose to trace the edges of things, (some people find it helpful to imagine that there is an incredibly long pencil extending from the tip of the nose).
Step 2: Move your head and eyes as you Sketch the edges of things near to you or far away, moving gracefully from object to object where their various edges intersect.
Step 3: As you practice this Sketching, notice the finer details of various objects—the leaves on a tree, the grain of a wooden floorboard, the inner and outer rims of a water glass, the eyelets and laces and stitching on a pair of shoes, etc. Sketch these objects' interior edges, as well as exterior.
Step 4: As with all exercises and vision habits, breathe deeply, relaxing the face, neck and shoulders.

What's Going On: By Sketching and noticing edges, the brain becomes interested in them and helps the eyes to sharpen the vision, thus reducing blur. Over time, you can Sketch objects with incredibly subtle movements of the head and eyes (as many people from non-western, less myopic cultures tend to do1). By Sketching regularly as an eye exercise, the eyes begin to do this naturally.

More Info:
• 1Thomas R. Quackenbush mentions the tendencies for most westerners to lock their necks whereas people in non-western countries tend to be more expressive in their head movements. See Quackenbus, Thomas R. Relearning to See. Berkeley: North Atlantic Books, 1997. This book also has a big section on Sketching.

The drawing above is by Philadelphia artist Jason Hsu and can be used as part of a Sketching exercise. I once saw Jason work on a single-line drawing—where he put his pen on a giant piece of paper and drew a picture without lifting the pen from the page—for 24 hours straight.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

14. Swaying & Swinging

The Idea: Everything around us is in motion. Walking down the street I see other people walking in various directions, bicycles and trolleys zooming up the avenue at different speeds, tree branches swaying in the wind, birds darting above against a backdrop of clouds floating leisurely across the sky. Even stationary objects appear to move when one is in motion. Riding the trolley past the park, the lampposts in the foreground appear to move by more quickly than the trees in the background, as dogs and squirrels and children run to and fro across the grass. All these things, moving in various ways, can be a soup of muddled vision for some. By accustoming the vision to motion, the eye-brain connection can learn to discern and differentiate the ingredients to that soup.

How To: Here are 2 versions of this exercise, each focusing on different depths of the visual field. Try doing them back-to-back, keeping the eyes and shoulders relaxed, breathing deeply:

Swaying:
Step 1: Hold one finger up about 30 cm in front of the nose.
Step 2. Keeping the finger where it is, shift your weight to your left foot and swing your head gently to the left so that the finger is visible only in the right eye. Next, shift your weight to your right foot, coming back though center, and then swinging your head gently to the right so that the finger is visible only in the left eye. Keep moving the head slowly from side to side with the weight of the body, looking straight ahead—not at the finger.
Step 3: Keep Swaying for 2-5 minutes, noticing the perceived movement of the finger. When you Sway to one side, which way does the finger appear to move in relation to the background?

Swinging:
Step 1: Hold one finger up about 30 cm in front of the nose.
Step 2. Keeping the finger in line with the nose, shift your weight to your left foot and swing your body in a 90º arc over to the left, moving the arm with the head. Next, shift your weight to your right foot, coming back though center, and then swinging over to the left. Keep moving from side to side with the weight of the body, looking straight ahead, finger still 30 cm in front of the face.
Step 3: Keep Swinging for 2-5 minutes, noticing the perceived movement of the background. When you Swing to one side, which way does the background appear to move in relation to the finger?

What's Going On: Swinging works with adjusting to background movements while keeping the eyes focused on something at a near distance. Swaying works with adjusting to closer movements while keeping the eyes focused on things at a medium or long distances. Both exercises together help the eyes stay focused without getting distracted, encouraging the brain to pick up this habit as well. Swinging and Swaying also help the body to loosen up, relaxing the muscles and helping to relax the eyes.

More Info:
• Swinging and Swaying are principle exercises in the Bates Method, developed by Dr. William H. Bate in the early 20th century, and espoused by many vision therapists today.
• Thomas R. Quackenbush’s paraphrasal of Bates is also a good one in his textbook Relearning to See (North Atlantic Books, 1997).
• This is a good exercise to pair up with the similar movements of Sunning.

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

13. Describing

The Idea: This 2-person exercise is best explained anecdotally:

Meir Schneider lived as a blind person up until his mid teens. He was able to discern light and shadow to some extent, but nothing else. He began working with natural vision teachers who would describe things that he could not see. "Do you see those buildings?" Meir Schneider could not see the buildings, but he could see a rough shadow of the buildings against the brightness of the sky above. Every day his teachers described the shapes of the buildings and each day Meir Schneider could discern more detail.

Then one day Meir Schneider was asked, "Do you see the windows on the buildings?" Meir Schneider could not see the windows on the buildings, but he could see brighter speckles in the shadow of the buildings from the light reflected off of the windows. Every day his teachers described the details of the windows and each day Meir Schneider could discern more visual information—how many rows of windows, how many windows in each row, and so on.

Next Meir Schneider was asked, "Do you see the air conditioners in the windows on the buildings?" Thus the therapy continued.

Today Meir Schneider teaches natural vision therapy in San Francisco. He has a drivers license.

How To:
• Work with a friend and look at something—a house, a tree, the skyline, a landscape—anything that you want to see. Ask each other questions about details of the thing.
• If one of you can discern more about what your looking at, that person becomes the Describer, helping the other to see things that were previously not perceived.
• Describing works best if its done consistently—preferably every day, possibly looking at the same subject, probably with the same Describer.
• If you want to switch roles, you can use technology—binoculars to zoom in on details, or mobile phones to relay information.

More Info:
• Meir Schneider shares many inspiring stories about his personal path toward visual rehabilitation in his Miracle Eyesight Method audiobook.

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

5. Palming

The Idea: Just as light can be used to heal the eyes, the eyes can also heal in darkness. Being able to see darkness can be tricky for some. If you are in a totally dark room with eyes closed, what do you see? Many people do not see total darkness, but patches of light, shimmering patterns, or glowing images. These things are not there in physical space and not even being seen by the eye—in order to see things, the eye needs light. These images are entirely in the mind. By relaxing both the mind and the eyes, a person Has the power to make these phantom shapes disappear.

Set Up: Palming can be done briefly in tandem with other eye exercises like Sunning and Directionals, and it's good to precede Palming with exercises to relax the neck and back. When practiced on its own, Palming is best done in a warm, dark place where you can support your head and elbows. Sit at a table with elbows propped on a pillow for comfort or support, or lie on your back with your head on a pillow and another pillow or folded blankets on your chest to support the arms. Get yourself into a position where you feel the least amount of tension in the neck and upper back.

How To:
• Step 1: Press your palms together and rub them vigorously, using friction to generate heat.
• Step 2: Close the eyes and cover them with your hands so that rims of the palms rest on the orbits (bones around the eye sockets), fingers resting on forehead. Take care not to put any pressure on the eyes themselves.
• Step 3: Breathe slowly and deeply through the nose. Relax.
• Step 4: Think of blackness. Should images come into your head, paint them black with your mind. Imagine that the entire world is totally black and in darkness.
• Step 5: Keep Palming for as long as you can—5, 10, 15 minutes to upwards of an hour—reathing, relaxing, and letting the mind drift into blackness.
• Step 6: When coming out of Palming, bring yourself slowly back to the lit world. Remove the hands and gently open the eyes. Find ways to segue smoothly into lit spaces rather than turning on bright lights right away. Palming can also be done right before going to sleep.

What's Going On:
• The heat generated by rubbing the palms together warms the eyes, increasing blood circulation and oxygen flow to cells. This helps the eyes to relax and regenerate.
• Healing systems that use meridian energy—the Qi of Chinese Medicine, Prana in ayurveda, etc.—demonstrate healing power in the hands. Palming brings rejuvenating intention to this practice, with the hands over the eyes completing an energy "circuit" in the body.
• According to natural vision therapist Meir Schneider, the images seen with eyes closed represent irritation on the optic nerve, and this also obstructs the vision when eyes are open. A portion of the optic nerve is in the retina at the back of the eye, but the optic nerve is actually part of the brain. By breathing, relaxing and meditating on blackness, we relax the brain, the optic nerve, and the sense of vision altogether. Schneider, who was born blind and once Palmed for 15 hours straight (right before he got his driver's license), states that only 50% of vision happens in the eye and that the other 50% happens in the brain. Dr. William H. Bates, who integrated Palming as part of his method in the early 20th century, had this ratio at 10% eye and 90% brain.

Testimonial: A man who suffered from macular degeneration once told me that he saw things when he closed his yes—"flickering spots and exploding checkerboards." We started palming together and he described what he saw. I said, "All that stuff you're seeing isn't in your eye, it's in your brain. You can make them go away but just imagining that everything is black." He let out a loud single laugh: "HA!" I asked why he was laughing. "It's gone," he said. "All I see is darkness. It's like night without any stars." He opened his eyes, thanked me, and walked away.

More Info:
• Palming can be found in the practice of yoga and is espoused by yogis like Swami Satchidananda's and Ana Forrest.
• Palming is one of the key eye exercises in the Bates Method created by William H. Bates. Meir Schneider gives a beautiful tutorial of Bates-style Palming in his Miracle Eyesight Method audiobook.
• I learned Palming from natural vision therapist Rosemary Gordon. If you can't visit her offices in Boston or Maine, you can at least watch her video here:

Friday, January 1, 2010

1. Sunning

The Idea: Photophobia (literally “fear of light”) is the eyes’ inability to deal with bright light and fluctuations in lighting (like going from a brightly lit space to a dark space or vice-versa). While mainstream western optometry recommends the aversionary tactics of "avoiding sunlight, closing the eyes, wearing dark glasses, or darkening the room" as temporary home remedies to photophobia, a more holistic method of self-healing is described here based on building up tolerance to sunlight rather than evading it.

Set Up: As the name implies, Sunning is best done using the sun, though a flood lamp or bright incandescent bulb can also be used.

How To:
• Step 1: Stand in a spot directly facing the sun, preferably in mid-morning of late afternoon when the sun is not too high in the sky, (this s to avoid neck strain). If using an electric light, place the lamp about 5 feet in front of you with the bulb a few inches above the height of the eyes.
• Step 2: Close the eyes and look at the sun. You will see sunlight in both eyes. Keeping the eyes closed, shift your weight to your left foot and swing your head gently to the left so that sunlight is visible only in the right eye. Next, shift your weight to your right foot, coming back though center, and then swinging your head gently to the right so that sunlight is visible only in the left eye. Keep moving the head slowly from side to side with the weight of the body, breathing deeply and relaxing facial muscles, shoulders, and the rest of the body. Do this for 2 to 10 minutes.
• Step 3: Turn around, facing away from the sun. Look around. What do you see?
• Step 4: Repeat Steps 1 through 3. Do you see things differently after Sunning a second time?

What’s Going On: Several things are happening through the practice of Sunning.
• First, as the head moves from side to side, the pupils are taking turns dilating and contracting. This regulates the shape of the pupils and exercises the eyes’ ability to do adjust to light and darkness.
• Second, the cone cells in the retina are also stimulated, sharpening central vision, day vision and color vision.
• Third, the sun’s heat warms the muscles and blood vessels around the eyes. This improves the flow of oxygen to the eyes, as well as the ability of the eye muscles to regulate eye movement and focal abilities.

Testimonial: I suffered from intense photophobia for over a decade and wore dark glasses most of the time—outside during the day, whether the sun was out or not, and even inside if a space was brightly lit. One summer I threw away my sunglasses and went on a cross-country trip where I practiced a battery of eye exercises called “The Bates Method,” Sunning being my favorite. Each time I Sunned I noticed an immediate temporary improvement in my vision with a gradual lasting improvement with regular practice. After two months I didn’t need my sunglasses anymore and other aspects of my vision had also improved.

More Info:
• Many people who practice and teach Sunning cite Dr. William H. Bates as its originator, though humans and other animals have used the sun both intentionally and instinctually long before Bates’ recommendation of “closed-eyelids sunning” in the 1920s.
• Meir Schneider’s Miracle Eyesight Method audiobook (published by Sounds True, 1996) gives an excellent follow-along tutorial on Sunning.
• Thomas R. Quackenbush’s paraphrasal of Bates is also a good one in his textbook Relearning to See (North Atlantic Books, 1997, pp. 229-231), appearing alongside his brief description of syntonics, or “healing with light.”
• I first learned Sunning from an awesome natural vision therapist named Rosemary Gordon. If you're ever in New England, pay her a visit!

Visitors:

º^º